![[info]](http://p-stat.livejournal.com/img/userinfo.gif){kind=small}
Abortion makes me sick
I can't believe it.
Wait - strike that. I can believe it, which makes it all the more depressing. While I was looking online for the rubric for an upcoming Goddess Religions assignment, I stumbled across another article posted on the class's electronic reserve page. This article is called "A Consistent Life Ethic?: Supporting Life After Birth" and is by Rosemary Radford Ruether, and can be found for free on this page. Considering that, on the class page, the article is referred to as "Abortion/Ruether," I of course was immediately curious, and opened it up.
Actually, the article itself is pretty impressive, when you consider that it manages to spend two pages critiquing the Catholic church without once even mentioning the Bible or anything even vaguely resembling God, AND that it covers almost every single one of the liberal hot issues: abortion, the war in Iraq (and with it the nation's completely failure to do anything good, in her not-so-humble opinion), global climate change, global disarmament, unfair distribution of wealth... am I missing anything? On second thought, it's not that special after all - she just shoved God out of the picture to make room for her pet issues. Typical.
I could spend a long time pulling apart her argument, especially her criticism that, because people will do it anyway, we should just concede that abortions are ok. That's very much like saying ,well, people will murder anyway, so we might as well make them legal, since it's not going to stop anything anyway. She cites some horrific case of a mother of three who was imprisoned for getting an abortion in some other country, and her three children were of course left completely helpless as she languished in jail. Depressing, certainly, and by no means is that the best way to go about punishing a woman for her bad decision - but does that mean that she is not in the wrong for choosing to end the child's life rather than seeking help? One of the girls who went on the Arizona mission trip with me shared her story - she was adopted, and her birth mother had had several abortions before becoming pregnant with my friend. She didn't say why her mother chose not to abort her, either, but she stated very clearly that she recognizes how easily she might have been aborted, too. No wonder she is against abortion.
But I digress. Regardless of whether or not I agree with a single word the Ruether says, what on earth is this article doing in my course reserves? Granted, it's not required reading - at least, not that I have seen so far. But, despite the fact that Ruether is a well-known feminist theologian, whose arguments I have encountered and refuted before, this article mentions nothing that is even vaguely related to goddesses OR religion. So, what is it doing on a list of offered readings for a goddess religions class? I'm no rocket scientist, but even I can clearly see that this article is way out of line. There is no reason whatsoever for her to post this other than to foist her own political beliefs onto us, her unwitting students. Never mind that most of the people in my class probably agree with the article. Never mind that it isn't required reading. This is WAY outside the scope of the class and has absolutely NO reason to be on that list. This sort of thing makes me absolutely livid. It's exactly what Indoctrinate-U is all about.
If I was not so close to graduation that I am scared of saying anything that would potentially jeopardize my chances of being done (I do need this class to graduate, sadly), I would try to do something about this. As it is, while I was already planning to give a scathing review on the course evaluations at the end of the semester, I now must remember to include this, as well. Perhaps I will included something to the effect of, 'Dr. Mitchell, I suggest you listen to the Right Brothers' song entitled "SHUT UP AND TEACH."'
It's almost too bad that I already have a calling. Otherwise, I might consider contacting Evan Maloney and seeing if he needed any help fighting the liberal indoctrination going on in our universities, because this is just plain wrong, folks. And it needs to stop.
-Jaya-
annoyedWait - strike that. I can believe it, which makes it all the more depressing. While I was looking online for the rubric for an upcoming Goddess Religions assignment, I stumbled across another article posted on the class's electronic reserve page. This article is called "A Consistent Life Ethic?: Supporting Life After Birth" and is by Rosemary Radford Ruether, and can be found for free on this page. Considering that, on the class page, the article is referred to as "Abortion/Ruether," I of course was immediately curious, and opened it up.
Actually, the article itself is pretty impressive, when you consider that it manages to spend two pages critiquing the Catholic church without once even mentioning the Bible or anything even vaguely resembling God, AND that it covers almost every single one of the liberal hot issues: abortion, the war in Iraq (and with it the nation's completely failure to do anything good, in her not-so-humble opinion), global climate change, global disarmament, unfair distribution of wealth... am I missing anything? On second thought, it's not that special after all - she just shoved God out of the picture to make room for her pet issues. Typical.
I could spend a long time pulling apart her argument, especially her criticism that, because people will do it anyway, we should just concede that abortions are ok. That's very much like saying ,well, people will murder anyway, so we might as well make them legal, since it's not going to stop anything anyway. She cites some horrific case of a mother of three who was imprisoned for getting an abortion in some other country, and her three children were of course left completely helpless as she languished in jail. Depressing, certainly, and by no means is that the best way to go about punishing a woman for her bad decision - but does that mean that she is not in the wrong for choosing to end the child's life rather than seeking help? One of the girls who went on the Arizona mission trip with me shared her story - she was adopted, and her birth mother had had several abortions before becoming pregnant with my friend. She didn't say why her mother chose not to abort her, either, but she stated very clearly that she recognizes how easily she might have been aborted, too. No wonder she is against abortion.
But I digress. Regardless of whether or not I agree with a single word the Ruether says, what on earth is this article doing in my course reserves? Granted, it's not required reading - at least, not that I have seen so far. But, despite the fact that Ruether is a well-known feminist theologian, whose arguments I have encountered and refuted before, this article mentions nothing that is even vaguely related to goddesses OR religion. So, what is it doing on a list of offered readings for a goddess religions class? I'm no rocket scientist, but even I can clearly see that this article is way out of line. There is no reason whatsoever for her to post this other than to foist her own political beliefs onto us, her unwitting students. Never mind that most of the people in my class probably agree with the article. Never mind that it isn't required reading. This is WAY outside the scope of the class and has absolutely NO reason to be on that list. This sort of thing makes me absolutely livid. It's exactly what Indoctrinate-U is all about.
If I was not so close to graduation that I am scared of saying anything that would potentially jeopardize my chances of being done (I do need this class to graduate, sadly), I would try to do something about this. As it is, while I was already planning to give a scathing review on the course evaluations at the end of the semester, I now must remember to include this, as well. Perhaps I will included something to the effect of, 'Dr. Mitchell, I suggest you listen to the Right Brothers' song entitled "SHUT UP AND TEACH."'
It's almost too bad that I already have a calling. Otherwise, I might consider contacting Evan Maloney and seeing if he needed any help fighting the liberal indoctrination going on in our universities, because this is just plain wrong, folks. And it needs to stop.
-Jaya-